The Differences Between Buying A Second Home vs Investment Property

Engel Lansburgh Team June 18, 2024

The Differences Between Buying A Second Home vs Investment Property

Real estate remains a popular channel for investment, offering potential for both personal enjoyment and financial gain. When venturing into real estate, buyers often consider purchasing a second home or an investment property. Though both options involve acquiring real estate, their purposes, benefits, and financial implications differ significantly. This comprehensive guide explores these differences to help you make an informed decision based on your financial goals and lifestyle preferences.

Defining Second Homes and Investment Properties

Second Home

A second home is typically purchased for personal use, often located in vacation destinations or areas where family members reside. These properties are used as a getaway for the owners, where they spend a considerable part of the year. The financing, insurance, and taxes for second homes can differ from primary residences due to their non-primary status.

Investment Property

This category includes properties purchased primarily to generate income, either through rental income, future appreciation, or both. Investment properties can be residential or commercial and are not typically used by the owner as frequently as a second home. The financial management of these properties focuses on maximizing returns.

Financial Considerations


Loans for second homes usually have similar interest rates to primary residences, but they may require a higher down payment and have stricter credit requirements due to the increased risk of default. On the other hand, investment properties generally come with higher interest rates and down payment requirements, reflecting the greater risk they pose to lenders.


For second homes, mortgage interest and property taxes are generally deductible, similar to primary residences. However, if the second home is rented out for more than a certain period annually, it must be reported as rental income. Investment properties benefit from broader tax deductions, including operating expenses, depreciation, and repairs.


Insurance premiums for second homes are often higher than for primary residences, especially if located in high-risk areas like flood, or fire zones, or hurricane-prone regions. Investment properties require landlord insurance, which covers the building, loss of income, and liability in case of accidents or injuries on the property.

Usage and Flexibility

Personal Enjoyment

Second homes offer personal and emotional value as they are often retreats for family and personal relaxation. Owners have the flexibility to decorate and use the property as they wish, aligning with personal tastes and comfort.

Rental Potential and Restrictions

Investment properties are primarily geared towards optimizing rental income and may be subject to different rules regarding rental periods and tenant rights. These properties might not offer the same personal use flexibility as second homes but provide financial benefits through ongoing income.


Local laws may affect both types of properties differently. For example, some resorts or communities might restrict short-term rentals, impacting the usage of second homes for income purposes. Conversely, investment properties might have regulations focusing on rental agreements, tenant rights, and rental income taxes.

Long-term Financial Goals

Resale Value

When purchasing a second home, the focus might not primarily be on appreciation. However, for an investment property, the potential for appreciation and the ability to sell the property for a significant profit can be a major consideration.

Cash Flow vs. Capital Gains

Investment properties are often evaluated on their ability to generate positive cash flow — consistent rental income exceeding the expenses associated with the property. In contrast, second homes are typically considered more for their long-term value and personal use, although they can also appreciate over time. Aspen has an amazing track record for appreciation!

Risk and Return

Market Risks

Both second homes and investment properties expose owners to real estate market fluctuations. However, investment properties typically offer a buffer through rental income, which can provide a steady income stream even in a volatile market.

Management Overhead

Managing an investment property can be more demanding than a second home, especially if it involves handling tenants, maintaining the property, and managing legal requirements related to rental properties.

Deciding between buying a second home or an investment property depends significantly on your lifestyle preferences, financial goals, and risk tolerance. A second home is suitable for those looking for a personal retreat and long-term family asset, while an investment property is ideal for those seeking to generate income and build wealth through real estate. Before making a decision, consider how each option aligns with your overall investment strategy and how you intend to manage the property. With careful consideration and strategic planning, real estate can be a rewarding addition to your investment portfolio, providing both tangible and financial benefits.

Partner with the Engel Lansburgh Team

Building a home in Aspen is a dream-worthy endeavor, but it requires a strategic approach and a team of seasoned professionals. The Engel Lansburgh Team stands at the forefront, armed with the knowledge, experience, and connections necessary to navigate the intricate landscape of Aspen's real estate development. Whether you are drawn to the convenience of  downtown Aspen, the tranquility of Snowmass Village, the rural  beauty of Woody Creek and Old Snowmass or the laid-back charm  of towns like Basalt and Carbondale in Garfield and Eagle Counties, we are here to guide you through every step.

If you're contemplating building or buying your dream home in Aspen or its surrounding areas, reach out to the Engel Lansburgh Team. Let our expertise transform your vision into reality. From understanding development restrictions to connecting you with the right professionals, we are committed to making your home-building journey in Aspen a seamless and rewarding experience.

Work With Us